Cindy Pennington, 58, of Spring Valley, Minn., died Jan. 1 in her home after a lengthy illness.
She was born April 7, 1950 in Austin, Minn. She grew up in Spring Valley and graduated from Spring Valley High School in 1968. She married Fred Larimer in 1971 and the couple moved to Long Beach, Calif. They later divorced and she moved back to Spring Valley in 2003.
She is survived by three sons, Chad Larimer of Rochester, Tim (Trisha) Larimer of Thayne, Wyo., and Jonathan Larimer of Spring Valley; four grandchildren; her parents, Virgil and Lillian Arett of Spring Valley; two brothers, Kyle (Debbie) Arett of Las Vegas, Nev., and Kent (Erika) Arett of Oak Park, Ill.; and her sister, Vicky (Jim) O’Connell of Spring Valley.
Something similar to what I just wrote above will be printed in the Post Bulletin on or about Monday, January 5. I am sure it will be fleshed out a little more, but it will be similar. My facts may be a little wrong – dates, addresses, etc.
My mother’s life will be reduced to a few column inches in a newspaper and that will be the end. The problem with an obituary is it really only provides a brief glimpse into what was somebody’s life.
I’m not going to use this as a place to air grievances against my mother. I am going to use this as a place to tell more than what a few inches of newsprint will ever tell you.
The statement, “…after a _____ illness…,” has always bothered me. In my mother’s case, it was a lengthy illness, but it was cancer. Cancer is a lengthy and terrible thing.
My mother was diagnosed with stage 4C ovarian cancer at Christmas in 2003. The doctor’s gave her about six months to live at the time.
A little background – in the 1980’s my mom had a hysterectomy. The doctors did not remove the ovaries at the time to prevent early onset menopause. Mom didn’t see a need to see a gynecologist because her reproductive organs had been removed so she didn’t see one. Had she seen a gynecologist, perhaps this cancer would have been detected earlier, but hindsight is 20/20.
Shortly after Christmas 2003, mom went under the knife. The surgeon discovered that the cancer had spread into the fat lining her abdomen. They removed as much as they could but he explained there was no way to get it all and that it would come back. She started receiving chemo and that became a constant up until this past summer.
Mom was a trooper and she defied the odds. She lived long enough to see my daughter born in 2004. She lived long enough to see another granddaughter born. Mom was indestructible. When things turned bad, we all got to the point that we didn’t believe the doctors when they said anything. Mom always found a way to beat it.
The cancer came back three times. She beat it twice. This past summer it came back again. The doctor told her she had a month to live. We took that with a grain of salt and told her that the doctors have never been right and reminded her that she was given six months nearly five years ago. Like Mayo Clinic oncologists know anything – they can’t even win seats in the House of Representatives.
The cancer had spread now. Stomach, liver, kidneys, lungs – it was everywhere. People ask me what kind of cancer my mom had and I would respond, “Everything cancer.”
The cancer caused my mom’s abdomen to fill with a fluid called ascites. It would make breathing difficult so the doctors frequently drained six liters of fluid from her abdomen. My mom did not waste away to nothing before she died – she swelled like a balloon.
On Christmas Eve, mom was having some trouble breathing, but that was not unusual. She had an appointment to have her abdomen drained that Friday, so we were not all that concerned. On Friday, as usual, they drained six liters.
Sunday, my brother called and informed me that the hospice nurse had stated that mom probably only had a few weeks to live. My response was, “Like we haven’t heard that before.”
Monday the hospice nurse informed him that her abdomen had already filled back up and that two weeks was now the maximum amount of time we could expect. The nurse also stated that by the end of the week mom would likely be severely confused and disoriented so now would be a good time for people to start visiting. I sat down with my boss and informed him of the situation and told him that beginning Friday (Jan. 2) that I would not be coming in to spend time with my mom. He was ok with this, his sister died of cancer as well.
I have been taking my daughter to my mom’s house every Tuesday for a long time. I called my brother to make sure that she was still ok for a visit on Tuesday. He stated she was.
I loaded my daughter up for what I knew would be her last visit with her grandma. I did not want this to drag out for her. We got to my mom’s house and it was hard. Mom was sliding fast. She recognized my daughter and they had a nice visit. Before we left I could see her slipping fast. We called my brother Tim in Wyoming and told him it was time to get in the car and haul ass.
I went to work Wednesday morning. I had an appointment and couldn’t cancel it. My brother called and told me that I should get my ass down there after work, the hospice nurse didn’t think that mom would make it through the evening. I left work early and spent New Year’s Eve holding mom’s hand. My mom was gone when I got to her house. A shell would best describe it. She was in a recliner but couldn’t get up anymore. She could talk, but it was brief (and occasionally funny). Mom was cold to the touch but complained of being hot. She wanted to go outside and shovel the sidewalk. You would have to know my mom, but there is no way in hell she would ever shovel the sidewalk. She would pay a neighbor kid before she ever attempted to lift a shovel.
As the evening wore on, it got worse and worse. I sat holding her hand talking to her all night. Watching her gasp for air is one of the most difficult things I have ever had to watch. Each breath was a full body effort. I commented that it looked like a fish out of water. She got belligerent and combative later in the evening. The last time she spoke was at around 2130 or 2200. I do not remember for sure. She wanted to get up again. She couldn’t but she was fighting to do it. We gave her more morphine at 2330. I gave her some more water. She slipped into a coma shortly after that. I held her hand and talked to her until the hospice nurse came at 0800.
We moved mom from the recliner to a bed. The nurse said it could drag on for a while, but she hoped it would be over that day (Jan. 1). She told me that my mom had told her Wednesday morning about me bringing my daughter to visit the night before and how much that meant to her. That made me feel better.
At about 1045 I left for a little bit. We needed more smokes and some pop. Mom died while I was out.
Heather called me at 0245, while I was holding mom’s hand to see how I was doing. I told her I was angry. That call meant a lot to me. Heather has been a rock for me the last few days. I don’t know how I will ever repay her. Last night was tough. Everything in my home is reminding me of my mom. Heather took me from my home and kept me overnight. She is an angel right now. The difference between me and insanity.
I said I was angry and was very angry. Watching someone suffer like that knowing that there is nothing you can do is a crushing thing. I got mad at the medical and pharmaceutical communities.
Cancer has been around a long time, but we haven’t done much to advance treatments or drugs. I understand it is complex but this is what pisses me off:
Most doctors and pharmaceutical executives are middle-aged men. Has anyone else noticed how the treatment of erectile dysfunction has advanced so quickly in the last few years?
We spend billions of dollars every year to make sure the middle aged guys can get their cocks hard so they can screw their twenty-something year old wives/girlfriends/mistresses but we cant get new cancer treatments?
I guess having a hard dick is more important than having living relatives.
Maybe the hardest part of all of this has been me trying to figure out how to explain to my daughter that her grandma is gone and that she will never see her again. It is bad enough to wake up and realize that you don’t have a mom anymore. I am an adult and understand that that is how life works. How do I explain that to a little kid who isn’t quite yet five years old?
I have a funeral to plan so need to cut this short.
More in the next few days.
Ladies – go to your OB/GYN. If not for yourselves, do it for me. All of this could have been preventable. Don’t let this happen to you or your loved ones.